Is Thurrott Laughing Yet?

December 3, 2007

A full six months after the hugely successful launch of Nintendo’s innovative Wii game console, PC and Windows “analysts” Paul Thurrott published a predictable piece about how Microsoft’s XBOX 360 was the console to beat. Despite Thurrott’s own “concerns about the 360’s reliability” he still felt that consumers would choose the XBOX over both the PS3 and especially the Nintendo Wii. He remarkably advised that except for parents with very young children, all others should “skip out on this console”, and called the Nintendo Wii “a joke”.

It’s now seven months later and the Wii buying season is upon us for the second time. The funny thing is, people are still lining up to get their hands on a Nintendo Wii. This weekend, I went to Best Buy here in Greensboro to finish up my Christmas shopping and arrived a bit before they opened at 10am. What I found was a line of about 50 people waiting outside the store. What were they waiting for? Had they braved the chilly morning air since 7am to snap up an XBOX 360 and a copy of Halo 3? Not in the least. The majority of these people were waiting to earn a chance to take home one of 18 Wii’s the store manager later told me had come in for the week. As I walked past the line I was reminded of Thurrott’s column and knew I couldn’t resist the urge to say “I told you so.”

In the span of less than a year, Wii sales have far outpaced those of the XBOX 360. I challenge you to walk into any electronics or toy store today and walk out with a Wii. People still can’t easily get a hold of the console, even though Nintendo ramped up production to 1.8 million units a month. If the Wii is a joke, then it’s one Nintendo’s laughing all the way to the bank. Depsite Microsoft’s success with Halo 3, Nintendo is making money hand over fist with each Wii sold. Not so for Microsoft, or especially SONY’s PS3, where margins are miniscule.

The Wii has once again secured Nintendo’s place in the halls of gaming history and proven that flashy graphics and all the cash in the world don’t make up for innovation, solid game play and word of mouth. Best of all though, it has shown that like many things he writes about, Paul Thurrott doesn’t have the first clue. I’m looking forward to playing Super Mario Galaxy over my holiday break and I hope all those people waiting in front of Best Buy this morning eventually get to play too. If you’re still on a quest for a Wii, remember to keep an eye out for one for Thurrott. After he takes his fifth or sixth XBOX back for repairs, maybe he’ll start to give Nintendo the respect they so rightfully deserve.

PS – I’m already bookmarking this gem that says Super Mario Galaxy sales figures won’t live up to expectations. With this kind of crack analysis from, you know it’s got to be reliable.

5 Responses to “Is Thurrott Laughing Yet?”

  1. As someone who wants a Wii, but bought an XBox 360 just so I could play Halo 3, it really doesn’t matter to me which platform is selling the best.. I just want to play fun games which all 3 platforms have (though I probably would have bought a Wii when I got my XBox, if I could find one).

  2. Jiffy Says:

    I love my Wii and have always been a Nintendo fan, but agree with Scott’s comment. The most important thing is to play fun games and that’s one thing the console competition doesn’t help. Gamers have to choose a console “team” before they can get the games and it’s no small investment. I wish more games were cross-console and not exclusive. Even so, I’m not going to buy a PS3 or an XBox 360 just to play a few games that look and have been reviewed to be excellent. I’ll stick with my Wii, a bit of Mario and Zelda, and enjoy.

  3. David Says:

    Don’t know if you heard or not, but Nintendo scored a 0 out of 10 on Greenpeace’s Greener Electronics Guide and Microsoft didn’t do much better at a 2.7.

    On the plus side, Apple has taken action to remove hazardous chemicals from their products and has since moved up on the list.

    Despite all this, we’re still considering a Wii purchase if one can be located ;-)

  4. Ged Says:

    The point about it doesn’t matter who’s selling the best, it’s about who has the best games is dead on. The problem with Thurrott was that he didn’t couldn’t get past the fact that the Wii’s graphics didn’t measure up to the XBOX or the PS3.

    As any arcade junkie can tell you, it’s not the eye candy that keeps you coming back, it’s how fun the game is. The Wii has this in spades, from Wii Sports to Zelda and now Super Mario Galaxy. Thurrott and others who dismissed Nintendo’s platform because of the perception that it was “just for kids” need to take a second look.

  5. David Says:

    Nintendo’s bet to tap the casual gamer market is definitely paying dividends for them. I believe most non-technophiles don’t care as much about “great graphics” of the PS3 or XBOX 360 as they do about the social aspects of the Wii. Case in point, it really didn’t matter to my Mom that there was a difference between HD channels and regular TV channels when my parents got that option.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: